Rabbis deliver apologies, new Korans to vandalized mosque
By Jonah Mandel10/05/2010 17:41 Jerusalem Post
Six of Gush Etzion’s most prominent rabbis visited the torched mosque in Beit Fajar on Tuesday to apologize for the destruction allegedly caused by Jewish vandals, and to deliver new Korans to the local imam in place of those burned in Monday’s pre-dawn arson attack on the West Bank house of worship.
Taking the books, a local religious leader said he was accepting them in the name of Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails.
Head of the Har Etzion yeshiva and nearby Alon Shvut resident Rabbi Aharon Lichtenstein and Efrat’s Chief Rabbi Shlomo Riskin were among those who heeded the call of Rabbi Menahem Froman, a Tekoa resident and longtime peace activist, to make the short trip to the mosque in the nearby village.
“What was done over there was frightful,” Lichtenstein told The Jerusalem Post, “terrible both morally and religiously.”
The US on Tuesday harshly condemned the mosque arson.
“We condemn this attack in the strongest terms and call for the perpetrators to be brought to justice. We note that Prime Minister [Binyamin] Netanyahu and Israeli Defense Minister Barak have also condemned the attack and have called for an investigation,” the US State Department said in a statement responding to reporters’ questions on the incident.
In Gush Etzion, the rabbis said the act ran counter to Jewish values.
“We came to apologize and express our shame in a threefold capacity,” said Lichtenstein – from a personal perspective, as representatives of Gush Etzion and in the name of the State of Israel.
“Going there, establishing contact, meeting the Palestinians face to face was especially meaningful,” Lichtenstein added, noting that the meeting had been positive and that the whole village, which in past years was considered hostile, had turned out for the encounter.
“People wanted to hear something positive,” he said. “I don’t delude myself that a conflict as sharp as what we have is going to be resolved in a short period of time. However, people feel that some progress might be made; morally it must be done,” he said. “I don’t see how we can stand by.”
The driving force behind the initiative was Froman, who in a conversation with the Post noted that this was already the third time he had paid such visits to vandalized West Bank mosques, believed to be the work of extreme Jewish elements exacting retribution.
The words “price tag” and “revenge” were also scrawled in black Hebrew letters over the stone doorway in Beit Fajar.
The two previous such occurrences were in Luban a-Sharkia and Yasuf, both in Samaria, where Froman utilized his good contacts within the Palestinian Authority to enable his presence on that sensitive turf.
This time, however, he approached the head of the IDF Civil Administration in Judea and Samaria, Brig.-Gen. Yoav Mordechai, who coordinated the visit with the higher echelons of the local Palestinian regime. Gush Etzion Regional Council head Shaul Goldstein and Efrat Mayor Oded Ravivi had also wanted to be part of the delegation, but the Palestinians only agreed to a group of six rabbis.
“This is a religious protest against those who object to peace,” Froman said of the visit, noting the central significance of peace in Judaism, expressed in prayer and even as one of the names of divinity.
“Of course we didn’t commit the arson, but it seems that somebody from my nation did,” he said.
Besides the rabbis who arrived in civil administration jeeps under heavy Palestinian security, members of the Eretzshalom (“landpeace”) movement, dedicated to promoting direct dialogue between settlers and Palestinians, also managed to arrive independently.
After the visit, a small clash erupted, with Palestinian youths throwing rocks at IDF soldiers, who responded with tear gas. There were no reports of casualties.
Goldstein told the Post that on Monday he had called Beit Fajar’s mayor to express his sympathy and outrage.
“I told him that no one knows who did it, and asked him not to immediately accuse the settlers or Jews at all,” Goldstein said.
However, he added, in the conversation with the mayor, that an act of arson against a mosque “was a crime, no matter who did it.”
As of press time, Judea and Samaria Police had still not released any information on their investigation into the incident.
Taking the books, a local religious leader said he was accepting them in the name of Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails.
Head of the Har Etzion yeshiva and nearby Alon Shvut resident Rabbi Aharon Lichtenstein and Efrat’s Chief Rabbi Shlomo Riskin were among those who heeded the call of Rabbi Menahem Froman, a Tekoa resident and longtime peace activist, to make the short trip to the mosque in the nearby village.
“What was done over there was frightful,” Lichtenstein told The Jerusalem Post, “terrible both morally and religiously.”
The US on Tuesday harshly condemned the mosque arson.
“We condemn this attack in the strongest terms and call for the perpetrators to be brought to justice. We note that Prime Minister [Binyamin] Netanyahu and Israeli Defense Minister Barak have also condemned the attack and have called for an investigation,” the US State Department said in a statement responding to reporters’ questions on the incident.
In Gush Etzion, the rabbis said the act ran counter to Jewish values.
“We came to apologize and express our shame in a threefold capacity,” said Lichtenstein – from a personal perspective, as representatives of Gush Etzion and in the name of the State of Israel.
“Going there, establishing contact, meeting the Palestinians face to face was especially meaningful,” Lichtenstein added, noting that the meeting had been positive and that the whole village, which in past years was considered hostile, had turned out for the encounter.
“People wanted to hear something positive,” he said. “I don’t delude myself that a conflict as sharp as what we have is going to be resolved in a short period of time. However, people feel that some progress might be made; morally it must be done,” he said. “I don’t see how we can stand by.”
The driving force behind the initiative was Froman, who in a conversation with the Post noted that this was already the third time he had paid such visits to vandalized West Bank mosques, believed to be the work of extreme Jewish elements exacting retribution.
The words “price tag” and “revenge” were also scrawled in black Hebrew letters over the stone doorway in Beit Fajar.
The two previous such occurrences were in Luban a-Sharkia and Yasuf, both in Samaria, where Froman utilized his good contacts within the Palestinian Authority to enable his presence on that sensitive turf.
This time, however, he approached the head of the IDF Civil Administration in Judea and Samaria, Brig.-Gen. Yoav Mordechai, who coordinated the visit with the higher echelons of the local Palestinian regime. Gush Etzion Regional Council head Shaul Goldstein and Efrat Mayor Oded Ravivi had also wanted to be part of the delegation, but the Palestinians only agreed to a group of six rabbis.
“This is a religious protest against those who object to peace,” Froman said of the visit, noting the central significance of peace in Judaism, expressed in prayer and even as one of the names of divinity.
“Of course we didn’t commit the arson, but it seems that somebody from my nation did,” he said.
Besides the rabbis who arrived in civil administration jeeps under heavy Palestinian security, members of the Eretzshalom (“landpeace”) movement, dedicated to promoting direct dialogue between settlers and Palestinians, also managed to arrive independently.
After the visit, a small clash erupted, with Palestinian youths throwing rocks at IDF soldiers, who responded with tear gas. There were no reports of casualties.
Goldstein told the Post that on Monday he had called Beit Fajar’s mayor to express his sympathy and outrage.
“I told him that no one knows who did it, and asked him not to immediately accuse the settlers or Jews at all,” Goldstein said.
However, he added, in the conversation with the mayor, that an act of arson against a mosque “was a crime, no matter who did it.”
As of press time, Judea and Samaria Police had still not released any information on their investigation into the incident.